The Nativity Story - A Review

Can yet another retelling be any good?

© Michelle Anderson

A review of the movie The Nativity Story. Is it just another cliched retelling or is it something to pay money to see?

Recently released for the Advent season, The Nativity Story is a retelling of the miraculous story of the birth of Jesus. Although nearly everyone on the planet knows the outcome of the story, the filmmakers successfully weaved throughout the story elements that left the audience with a somewhat different take on what could have easily been another clichéd telling.

In the film, we meet Joseph and Mary not as the Saints we know, but as the people they were. The fact that they would be the parents of Christ notwithstanding, the film, through subtlety and bluntness, paints a picture of what life was truly like in those times.

We see how Herod, though wise, was blinded by utter greed and the desperate attempt to remain in power. We feel how terribly and unjustly the Roman soldiers carried out their orders. We see families torn apart, the gathering unrest, and the sheer effort it took just to exist.

What is possibly the best portrayal yet of Mary’s ordeal and her faith is seen in this film. We get a strong sense of the risk she took in saying yes to God. The risk of stoning was all too real, let alone shunning, etc. We see Joseph as a man not too caught up in his own pride when faced with the idea of an illegitimate child to spare Mary the worst of public ridicule.

Finally, we see not just the emotional, but the very real physical toll of the journey to Bethlehem. This arduous journey did not only inflict pain on the pregnant Mary, but also the selfless Joseph. The most endearing part of the film was how it showed these two people, virtual strangers at the time of their marriage and journey, reached out to each other through their faith in God to embrace all the doubts and fears they harbored. This film portrays a faithful humanity. It’s one to own and add to your collection of favorites.


The copyright of the article The Nativity Story - A Review in Catholicism is owned by Michelle Anderson. Permission to republish The Nativity Story - A Review must be granted by the author in writing.



Comments
Dec 11, 2006 4:11 PM
Michelle Anderson :
What Christmas-themed movies do you like?
Dec 12, 2006 8:30 AM
Brian Tubbs :
I too liked the movie. My wife and I really enjoyed it. I wish Hollywood would do more like it.

Your review mentions (and admittedly the movie itself seems to depict) Roman soldiers carrying out Herod's orders to slaughter the babies in Bethlehem. I personally don't think the Romans did that. The Romans were interesed in preserving stability. Killing children tends to destabilize things. I don't think they'd want such an uprising on their hands. They were, after all, not very popular in Judea to begin with.

My understanding has always been that Herod's men carried out this deed. Not the Romans. I understand that Herod was under Roman authority, but it's not inconceivable that he "freelanced" on this - just as I'm sure the Romans had nothing to do with Herod killing off his wife and sons. Was it Augustus who said that he'd rather be Herod's pig than Herod's son?
Dec 13, 2006 5:18 AM
Michelle Anderson :
Not to mince words but I used Roman because ultimately they had declared loyalty to Rome under Herod. But I guess that is mincing words. I was trying to find a way to encapsulate not just the slaughter but the tax collectors, who worked for Rome and Herod also and the way the Romans treated the Jews in totality.

I also found it interesting they put in that line with Mary's father questioning whether the soldiers did this to her. While she would have still been shamed, I think it would have been easier for her to say yes to this.
Page:
3 Comments

Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo